Race     Minutes to Post     Track Conditions     Handicapper Picks    

Expert Picks

Jeremy Plonk

Jeremy Plonk is the owner of Horse Player NOW, the racing industry's leading fan education and player development website and creator of the Night School program. He has been a Keeneland handicapping consultant since 2008 and was lead statistician/researcher for more than 50 Triple Crown telecasts on NBC, ABC and ESPN for 18 years.

Jeremy Plonk’s Keeneland Keys for Friday, October 23, 2026

What to Watch for Today: The next-to-last card of the Fall Meet brings our first stakes of Week 4 with the co-featured Myrtlewood and Grade 3 Valley going back-to-back in Races 8 and 9. Two turf races are on the schedule (Races 7 & 9), so no Keeneland Turf Pick 3 today.

Handicapping Head-start: Be sure to join me at 8:30 pm ET on the night before each racing day’s card for the Keeneland Look-Ahead video podcast. It streams live on the Keeneland YouTube page as well on Twitter @Keenelandracing and @Horseplayernow. Catch the archives at your leisure if you can’t make it live, Please subscribe to both channels if you get the chance.

Weather: Fingers crossed, the entire week looks fabulous around 70 degrees and sun.

My Selections: You can get my top 3 picks in each race on the track simulcast feed before each race as well on the Keeneland.com handicappers’ consensus page (https://www.keeneland.com/racing/wagering/handicappers-consensus).

Keeneland Handicapping 101: Most information is gleaned from the free Keeneland Handicapping database (http://apps.keeneland.com/awstats/Default.asp) that you can manipulate and search for yourself as well!

Morning Movers: Utilize Keeneland’s free video workout database, courtesy of the KTDF, here: https://www.keeneland.com/racing/workout-videos. It’s another great, free handicapping tool for betting Keeneland.

1st Race

Elder maiden claimers sprint 6-1/2 furlongs to open the early pick 5. The 17 maiden claimers this meet have seen an average winner just 3-1 odds with none over 6-1 odds and favorites going 7-17. Kentucky Downs and Churchill preppers lead the way with 4 wins apiece (with no KD reps here, the CD alumni should be effective). Favoritism here likely falls on One More Time for Bob Baffert in a race with few promising options. Jockey Tyler Gaffalione has been a Week 4 dynamo at Keeneland over the last 5 years and started this closing week hot on Wednesday. Baffert is 1-for-9 in limited MCL races since 2025 with 4 losses at 3-1 or less odds, so I’ll try to find an alternative. Terre Haute has been running much farther than his damside pedigree suggests and may be more effective as a closing sprinter as was his Turfway debut in March. But getting John Ennis off an 0-for-the-meet deserves some value if buying. Tough group to embrace.

2nd Race

Starter allowance runners compete over 7 furlongs in the start to the early pick 4. Churchill preppers have won 8 of 12 starter allowance races this meet. The average starter allowance winner at the meet is just 3-1 odds (1 over 5-1, high 8-1). Sassy Princess exits a good third at Churchill behind Talking In Cursive, who since has returned at the Kee meet to win an Oct. 16 starter allowance. Sassy Princess was a romping 7F winner here during the Spring Meet in allowance company and lands top Week 4 jockey Tyler Gaffalione. Note 10 of 11 starter allowance winners this meet had started from Aug. 22-on, so long layoff runners like Our Liberty Belle would be trying to buck that. Her trainer Joe Sharp’s runners have been on point at the meet and got Week 4 off to a red-hot start on Wednesday. Price players beware Fugitive Star off a good second going longer here Oct. 11 as jockey Luis Saez is a maestro over the 7F trip at Kee.

3rd Race

Two-year-old maiden claimers route over 1 mile on dirt in this one. We’ve had 38 MCL routes for 2YOs in Fall Meets, but this is our first this season. Favorites are 19-38 with an average winner 4-1 odds. Of the 38 winners, 32 had experience and just 6 were first-time starters. Churchill preppers have a strong 18-4 edge over Ellis at next-best. Seven of these 12 have CD experience in tow, and it’s Newhope that interests me most off a debut fourth. The winner won by 11-1/2 that day but note we saw trainer Lindsay Schultz pop a $25 winner in a similar 2YO MCL dirt route last Fall Meet. Brad Cox hasn’t had his typical meet but he’s 6-18 with 2YO MCL routes in Fall Meets in past years and has Soccer Socks. The Cox barn has dominated Week 4 results over the last 5 years at Kee Fall Meets. The best of the rookies may be Kenny McPeek’s Cover Story. That barn also has strong Week 4 success historically (and won a race here Wed to open Week 4). McPeek is 9-19 in the exacta with 2YO MCL dirt routers at Kee.

4th Race

High-end $62,500 claimers match up in this about 7-furlong affair. Favorites are 6-23 in CLM races this Fall Meet with an average winner 6-1 odds, so while 8-5 morning line chalk Ghazaaly would be no surprise to win as he did in his only other Kee raid, it’s fair to shop a bit.  Trainer David Jacobson tries to make Tarantino the only 2-time winner at the meet while stepping up in class mildly. We’ve had 23 Fall Meet open claiming races for $50,000 or higher pricetags since returning to dirt in Fall 2014, and these have been very honest races in terms of returns (avg winner 9-2 odds, favorites won 8-23). A slight cut-back in distance has been effective at this class level and 7F trip, 4 of 7 shortening the distance off their most-recent prep. Give 7F ace rider Luis Saez every chance with Colonial miler Break Out on the cutback from a positive, outside draw.

5th Race

Friday’s pick 6 begins with a starter allowance at 1-1/16 miles on dirt. Churchill preppers have won 8 of 12 starter allowance races this meet. The average starter allowance winner at the meet is just 3-1 odds (1 over 5-1, high 8-1). The morning line favorite is a lukewarm 7-2 (Belmont Stakes also-ran Vitruvian Man) in a pretty wide open cast, a far cry from the 4 STR ALW routes this meet that have been win by 4/5, 3/2, 2-1 and 4-1 shots. Note that Jets Rio and South Bend Tom come out of the same Sept. 27 race at Churchill in which Rugged Love won – and that rival came back on the class rise to allowance company here Wednesday and ran a dynamite third by 2 heads against tougher competition. Early speed has been very strong in 2-turn routes this Fall Meet on dirt so the stretch-out speed of Ghostwritten really intrigues me in a race without that much pace. Could be a big day for Luis Saez if we’re right.

6th Race

Two-year-old maiden special weight sprinters make a rare 5-1/2 furlong dirt dash appearance in the late pick 5 kickoff leg. We’ve only had 5 such races offered in Fall Meets, the last of which came in 2023. As you might suspect with young dashers, Wesley Ward won 2 of those 5 races and will have rookie Tarkanian in the hunt. Note both of Ward’s winners in these spots did have experience (though 2 of 5 winners were debut runners for other barns). Bob Baffert debuts the Justify colt Justico and should be well-backed by the public. I was mixed vibes watching the workout videos despite the fast times. Baffert did win a debut 2YO here in the Fall of 2022 with Arabian Knight’s unveiling at 3-5 odds. Trainer Steve Asmussen’s 10 wins at the meet include 6 with 2YO MSWs like this and 3 by offspring of first-crop sire Jackie’s Warrior. Enter TV Time Out for a second chance at the meet after battling up top here opening day and now getting a shorter trip.

7th Race

First-level (N1X) allowance runners go 1-1/16 miles on turf in 1 of 2 grass races slated for Friday. This race begins the late pick 4. We’ve had 7 turf route ALW races at this meet through 3 weeks, favorites winning 4 and average winner at 7-2 odds. The average winner has been 1-3/4 lengths back after the first half-mile with only 1 winner closing more than 3 lengths. Kentucky Downs preppers hold a 4-2 edge over Colonial Downs with winners. I like 4-time winner Lucky Mischief off the claim for Mike Maker and an immediate jockey move to John Velazquez. Maker also has 1 of 2 KD reps in the field with Gun Barrel City, the other being also-eligible Fuzzbuster, who scratched from a dirt race Wednesday to await a chance here. Quick Pick should be formidable for a Will Walden barn that’s been on point with limited starters at the meet.

8th Race

The $300,000 Myrtlewood Stakes matches 2-year-old filly sprinters over 6 furlongs in the first leg of the $3 Late Pick 3. This race has been run 5 times since its 2021 debut, making it one of Keeneland’s youngest stakes races. All 5 winners were 7-2 or less odds with 3 favorites. The average winner is 1 length off the lead after the first half-mile with no winners closing more than 2-1/2 lengths from that point. The Churchill September meet has produced 4 of the 5 winners, which points to runners like Miss Anna, Cruisin in Harmony and my top pick Elewene. The move here to money rider Jose Ortiz matters in a race like this and trainer Dale Romans’ runners at Kee Fall Meets tend to run to expectations. Sire Jackie’s Warrior has had a fantastic meet with his first crop of 2YOs and will be repped by Rescue Dawn, while Girvin can say the came and has Miss Anna here. Trainer Brad Cox won this stakes in 2022 and 2023 and looks for another with Angel of Kirk, who was third last out behind eventual Alcibiades runner-up Summer Starlet.

9th Race

Friday’s featured race is the Grade 2 $400,000 Valley View Stakes at 1 mile on turf for 3-year-old fillies. One of the craziest stats of the Keeneland Fall Meets is that favorites have lost 18 straight Valley View editions on turf and have just 1 win in the 20 such races in our database. The average winner has been a whopping 10.3-1 odds. The race used to be 1-1/16 miles but was reduced to a mile the last 3 years. The average winner in those few miles was 4 lengths back after the first half-mile. Trainer Rusty Arnold won this race in 2021 with Navratalova and 20-24 with Poolside with Slim and I like his chances with Call On Me, who broke her maiden here in the Spring in a long line of Twirling Candys who’ve succeeded here. The ran into a moster in Kentucky Belle in the Dueling Grounds Oaks last time and can bounce back. Likely favorite Sister Troienne comes out of the right prep circuit has 7 winners of the Valley View in the last 20 years prepped in New York, Kentucky Downs next-best with 4. Irish-bred Define has yet to run at Keeneland but don’t be surprised if she likes it – the Lope de Vega offspring have been very strong here in limited chances over the years.

10th Race

The finale is a 1-1/16 miles maiden special weight on dirt for elders and serves as the Toyota Super High 5 race. We have 29 such elder MSW dirt routes in the Fall Meet in our database and while favorites underperform at 8-29, the average winner is only 4-1 odds, shorter than average of all divisions. Over 2-29 winner topped 8-1, one of those coming during this meet when a category-high 13 upsetter occurred Oct. 15. Todd Pletcher’s 3 wins in such races are most of any barn and he’ll have Sesasi here. Pletcher has been strong with the Saratoga to Keeneland dirt MSW transitions over the years, winning earlier this meet with Damavand, who is pre-entered now in the Breeders’ Cup Juvenile. Interestingly 5 of the 10 entrants in this race are sons of Gun Runner, whose overall Kee dirt route numbers are terribly weak despite high-profile stakes winners like Further Ado, Sierra Leone and Locked.